About Nonna's Pizzeria
59 Yelp Reviews
cjaquilino11/27/22, 5:51 p.m.
Mediumly thin, medium baked brown undercarriage, tart small chunked tomato sauce with light oregano, pretty good sauce to cheese ratio, with a moderately chewy and aerated crust It's fine pizza but average. I usually blather on in my reviews. But I think this one doesn't need much more analysis. I respect the fact that they sell a tomato pie. Out of the Northern Westchester Nonna's, Peekskill and Buchanan's are the better of the four of them. Go here for the specialty slices and Italian America menu items.
mr.mozzerella3/29/20, 9:18 p.m.
The slice is served hot in 2-3 minutes. Visually, it is not very appealing. Very little Mozzarella on the slice. The sauce has a big tang and is overpowered with oregano. The crust is very, very doughy with a fermented flavor. After 2 bites I wanted to throw the slice away and eat the napkin. By far one of the saddest sliced I’ve had in a long while. This isn’t even better than a dollar slice in the city!
danny.rez5/1/19, 10:15 p.m.
Great Football Pizza. Solid slice, grandmas slice is good too. One bite.
lou.p12/29/18, 8:21 p.m.
We had 2 styles: Classic/football pizza And "Grandma" Which is like a fancy thin crust square sliced pizza. Scoring only the Classic cheese so its an official President Score: The cheese was thick and the sauce is very tasty! But the crust is not as crispy as I'd like.
pizzascientist11/5/18, 6:58 p.m.
Huge slice with good ingredients. Consistent taste throughout.