NY Pizza Suprema

Crust in most NYC places is good. Sauce could have a more distinctive flavor

Presentation isn't great, but sauce and crust don't disappoint. Definitely a midtown slice, but better than works in a pinch.

Very good crispy, love the flavor Good crust

Best per slice pizza I’ve had yet. Got “the sausage” and “the fig” for a little savory and sweet.

Kinda sloppy when Portnoy isn’t visiting - but tastes good

Best Pizza I found in Manhattan. Right next to the garden / train station. It’s awesome.

Review 502… tremendous slice No flop. Excellent sauce w a kick. Cheese was good nice ratio. Delicious crisp to crust. Needs some char undercarriage $5.00 slice. Busy place

NY pizza Suprema upside down slice is delicious, great crisp, the sauce is in sweeter side but thick and delicious, highly recommend. Also had the fra diavolo slice which is loaded with pepperoni, not as crisp and frankly not as good. 7.2. They only had one regular slice left and my son had it, he gave it a solid 8.6 but I didn’t have one. For a good NY slice and a lot of options , give NY Pizza Suprema a shot. Right across the street from MSG.

Great crisp tangy sauce, too much oregano

Good crisp, too much oregano

Great Crust too much sauce , quality cheese solid slices but not as high as rated

Great flavors, crust is on point! Also tried the upside down Sicilian… loved it!!

Hot Honey slice

Great pizza, tons of options, by the slice is the way to go. Upside down slice was delicious.

Diavola and regular slice

Solid NY slice Upside Down 7.9 Burrata slice 7.5 White w Hot Honey 7.1 Mushroom 7.8