NY Pizza Suprema

Piping hot. Shit is hitting. Solid muzz. No flip. Good sauce.

My expectations here were a little lower - L’Industrie the day before, last stop of the trip, right across from Penn, felt a little touristy…doesn’t matter. Second best slice of the trip, SUPER NICE people, great flavor and lots of options.

I got there late and the only cheese slices they had looked like they had been sitting for a while so I went with the upside down slice. Nice sauce and cheese, crust is pillowy except by the crust. They didn’t heat it up enough so it was only lukewarm. I expected better.

Stopped here following a concert at MSG. Great location. I ordered the pepperoni slice and it was extremely greasy. I needed a few napkins on it. It was scorching hot even after several minutes. However, good crisp and good ingredients!

I didnt like it at all. Too much sauce. Messy.

Lots of sauce which I like. Crispy bottom, not that much cheese. Sauce tasted fresh. Very solid

Lots of sauce, but still good

Great undercarriage and I like the sauce! Very good

Cheese slice was nice and crispy with a perfect tomato sauce. Topping pizzas were lower in quality though

One of the best NYC slice shops Fresh, tomatoey sauce; right amount of cheesy; crispy crust without being burnt Also a decent sized slice

Pizza was solid. I had the cheese and a buffalo chicken ranch. This is solely off of a cheese review. Good hold and solid cheese but the flavor of the sauce was ok in my opinion. Would go again after a game at MSG

Great slice, priced at 4.75, amazing sauce with perfect herb blend, crust was crispy enough, and the cheese was tasty but a bit too sparse, 8/10 would come back after a knicks game

Floopppppy, cheese is delish and sauce is complimentary. Needs char

Burrata slice. That’s some New York flop right there. This one surprised me at how good it was. A thin pie but great distribution of toppings. Fresh basil like Di Fara was a great touch. Loads of choice here.

New York Pizza Suprema - Slice Style: New York * Appearance/Presentation: 4/5 * Notes: classico, grease pool * Taste: 4.7 * Sauce/Cheese/Topping: 4.3/5 * Notes: Oily af but didn’t sacrifice the structure * Dough: 4.8/5 * Notes: Burnt-ish undercarriage but good integrity * Crust: 4.5/5 * Notes: Crunchy * Total Score (25 max.): 22/25 = 8.9/10 - Price (worth it?): $7/slice (eh) - Additional Notes: pricy but quality - Had white/garlic & hot/honey

Among my favorite slices in NY! Margherita square was really good, the sauce is a bit on the sweet side (though I do personally prefer it that way). Upside down is seriously great— the crust is nice and fluffy (it feels like eating a cloud) and the sauce is just the right amount of sweet for me, and not overwhelmingly cheesy.

Great pizza right outside MSG