Passalinqua's Pizzeria

Visually, this is a home run! But it doesn’t quite live up to how good it looks, unfortunately. I know a lot of folks talk this place up but for whatever reason, it just doesn’t really do it for me and I wonder why I can’t see what they all see here. The dough is very good, but fairly floppy in the middle, not much crisp at all. The pepperoni is probably the highlight here (those are plenty crispy) and the cheese is about as average as you can expect. Totally fine. The sauce (which I believe is made in-house) really drags this down and that’s a real darn shame because there’s a lot of it. I’m sure it’s great on a pasta but I’m not digging it on this pizza. Sprinkling some herbs on this was a nice touch from them, though. Overall, it’s a meh from me.

Located next to Presque Isle Pickleball. This small hidden Pizza place has delicious pizza. The crust is medium thickness and the cheese and pepperoni toppings are generous. The sauce is very flavorful and tasty. Give it a try!

They certainly aren’t shy on the toppings, and we ordered a lot of them (green peppers, pepperoni, mushroom), but the quality of said toppings is standard canned stuff, the presentation is sloppy and the taste isn’t terribly strong. Reminds me a bit of Vocelli; chewy, decently satisfying, not my favorite.