Pizza Barn

Good taste a lot of cheese and a little on the greasy side.

Had it at a party. Didn’t get to have the cheese tho — (had the meatlovers and also pepperoni). Overall, isn’t somewhere I’d go on my own but good football pizza

Established in 1975, this joint has been a staple of the Yonkers pizza scene for nearly 50 years. However, they’ve been serving the “Super Slice” only since 2016, which is essentially a 2-foot gimmick pizza that’s cut into squares, giving off slice-shaped Sicilian vibes. Super thick & doughy, this is really one big novelty act, perfect for children’s birthday parties, with a look, style, texture & taste that equals quantity over quality. Super soft with minimal crisp, the dough is moderately thick & slightly undercooked, in need of some more time in the oven. Mostly bland, the dough has a dull flavor with a Sicilian style texture & Greek dough taste. Despite a fairly firm undercarriage, there’s virtually no crisp or crunch, barely even in the paltry perimeter of the buttery crust. The cheese appears to be a pretty basic shredded mozzarella blend with rather generic flavor & a consistency that lacks creaminess. Poorly melted in some spots, the flow of the cheese is also interrupted by several pizza bubbles creating a void of taste. The texture & flavor of the cheese is equally forgettable. Short on seasoning & lacking personality, the sauce is not as bland as the dough but lacks spice & kick, leaving the flavor flat. More acidic than sweet, the sauce is a disappointingly generic tomato blend that needs more pizzazz to avoid the oversized pizza gimmick label. This pie profiles as late-night drunk pizza, more filling than flavorful, not premier pizza whatsoever. Perfect party pizza, especially for a kid’s birthday, Instagramable social media ginormous gimmick pizza with more shock value style than delectable substance, this is clear quantity over quality hunger-curing pizza. Unless you just want to see this monster “slice” for yourself, this is not travel-worthy pizza; and at a price point of damn near $30, I’d much rather pay for a top-notch, fancy & delicious New York pie in the city of legendary pizza.

The grandma slice bumped up the average

This giant pizza had great taste.

Was really good

It is good but really doughing

Not a bad slice. Good drunk pizza for sure.

I actually really like this enormous slice, which in reality is a pie shaped like a slice. The sauce is yummy, the undercarriage is good, but the crust is a little doughy, like it could have used another minute or two in the oven, but excellent for a gimmick pizza

Zero flop, super greasy, bready thick crust even for the thin pie…skip the pepperoni.

Massive slices, but no flop. Very greasy. Football pizza. Good crunch. Good taste.

Solid pizza. Good cheese, good sauce, and it’s not too greasy. My biggest issue with it is that it’s too doughy for my liking. If you’re into thin and crispy pizzas (like me), this place isn’t the greatest. The super slice is great for parties, though!

I had low expectations, but it was good. Good crisp, but still kind of fluffy. Flavorful cheese and sauce. A little heavy, but pretty enjoyable. Great people in there too.

Sadly they have lost their touch! Greasy, with no flavor whatsoever , an utter disappointment

This place has not only huge slices to share but a great variety of slices to pick from. This one was definitely heavy but had great taste. Small Inside but worth the wait.