Prince Street Pizza

Amazing square.

The Penguin

Cheese was a little sloppy, but the sauce was amazing. The regular cheese had no flop with a good crunch. The pepperoni square was equally as good. Well worth the wait in line!!

Slightly cold, didn’t live up to the hype

Disclosure: rating is for the traditional slice. A little greasy but amazing sauce and crisp. Lived up to the hype. Regarding the square slice…. 8.4 . There I said it. Very very good. Amazing crisp and undercarriage. Worth the trip. Also lived up to the hype

8.3 on the regular cheese, very good, nice crisp, very cool unique sauce, but a Little heavy. Bonus rating, Sicilian gets an 8.5 - beautiful flaky crispy crust, great sauce, could’ve used a touch more cheese but a star Sicilian.

Got the four cheese and the spicy vodka. Both very good slices. Nice crunch, sauce is tasty, and the cheese is plentiful. Four cheese is a 8.2 and vodka a 8.4.

The Spicy Spring was excellent. Lived up to the hype.

Wow. This was a delicious pie.

Nice and thicc

I don’t want to crush it, still a good pie. But it’s turned into a bit of a tourist turnstile.

For deep dish this was a very light tasty pie. I thoroughly enjoyed the pep and we tried the vodka which was my boyfriend decision, should have stuck with the pep..

Could be on the mt rushmore of square slices, im a regular slice guy but they were slinging square slices like a printing press. Old time spot, glad i came 🇮🇹

Holy fucking shit man I love prince St. you haveeee to get the square but the OG margarita is insane too

The spicy pepperoni is awesome. Good crunch, nice spice with both the pepperoni and the sauce itself.

Decent pizza. No flop. Sauce wasn’t too memorable. Was expecting more from this place. Good crunch at least.