Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room

For a wood fired pizza the crust was WAY too thick, with no char. Sauce is basically nonexistent and the sweet sausage really had no flavor. Sadly there was nothing I liked about this pizza despite the reviews. Honestly just an average pizza. Would not go out of my way to get this one.

Got the white sauce pizza. Very good crust has great flavor

Great sauce good crisp Good slice

Went here for a birthday dinner (1/12) First time experiencing brick oven cooked pizza. It was really good but pretty average too

Picture does not do it justice. This is actually a very solid pie very thin and light. dough was fluffy and the crust is pretty good but after about seven slices the crust got to be a bit much so I would recommend getting a side of sauce for the crust, but also the sauce can be used on pizza in hole as it was a tad lite on sauce. overall good fire oven pie 7.8

Little flop, but was a good pie overall

Was looking forward to trying their pizza as it’s rated one of the highest in Pittsburgh. However, it was very disappointing. Pizza was extremely thin, so thin that it was soggy and couldn’t hold a single topping. As I picked up my first slice, literally everything slid off and I was left with a paper thin, soggy piece of bread. Calamari 8/10 though!

Pizza is pretty solid. Everything was really good

Great crust. Tangy sauce. Not my ideal style but exactly as advertised.

These fancy pizzas just aren’t doing it for me anymore. I feel like it takes away a lot of qualities that makes pizza so good in the first place. Each bite had the same soft texture, even in the crust. The sauce and cheese were definitely fresh, but the way it was dispersed on the pizza left something to be desired. I would definitely prefer something super greasy than something small and expensive like this pizza.

Carnivore Proper Pizza was amazing!

Delicious Mediterranean pizza

Good crust. Little to no flop. Mozzarella didn’t quite get melted to where I like it or I’d have given above an 8. Solid pie.

The brick oven is a nice touch, the crust had a good char. The sauce was very sweet. Good, average pizza. Nothing to go too far out of your way for.

Solid pie

This pizza made me wet

Sauce is sweet, which usually isn’t my style, but it’s just plain delicious. Crust is thicker than I prefer, and not enough crisp. Great tasting pie though and even better locale.