Renato's Pizza Masters

-1 point canned shrooms

Sicilian was a good slice. Nothing to write home about I’d give it a 7.2 the sausage pizza was amazing it definitely is a 8.3

Well done !

Delicious! Great firm bite with a nice crunch to it and the cheese parts just perfectly.

Free pizza at work? Gets a little half point bump for that!

Nothing special or unique, just a normal pizza done really well.

Solid traditional pizza

Very good and great taste

Best pizza in jersey city

Buffalo chicken pizza not the best and they burnt the crust a little

I'm a bit shocked about some of the low scores I've been seeing. Here's the real story. Been coming here for years. You kinda need to know when to order bc the place gets really busy sometimes. Order fresh whole pies, one of the few places where a fresh pie is better than a reheated slice. Beyond that certain people work on certain days so be smart and order off-peak. I suggest a bit of seasoning (Gar, Parm, Pep, crushed RP) if you like that kind of stuff bc the sauce focuses on the premium tomatoes with a light but good balance of cheese. I'm not a "bar pie" guy so was surprised but delighted by Dave's review. 100% do a front than back 1st bite. The crust is what sets this place apart from others. They topping are high quality but the cheese can stand on its own. For my taste just go regular and don't over think it. The fresh mozzarella version I see people going with shouldn't be how you judge this place. I like traditional salty whole milk muzz. Worth reading some Google reviews for the kitchen stuff.

In hindsight, if I let the slice cool down a bit and settle I think it could have been low 7’s. But as it was I felt fine giving a 6.8. Nice crisp crust and liked that there was no flop, but an average flavor.

Quite generic pizza solid though I’m right with the community score

Vodka pie was very good, medium dough and could have been cooked a minute or two longer, and a lot of cheese

Excellent pizza! I recommend the eggplant and fresh garlic as toppings! Service was excellent. A touch more salt and this would have been an 8.1

Lots of cheese, good crisp, sauce is ok.

Floppy af. Great sauce, very greasy.

Very tasty, enjoy the crust and the cheese to sauce ratio, Little floppy with a little too much grease but overall a good slice

Deec.

I came in last night because of Dave's review. I don't know why he gave it such a good score. I was disappointed. Too thick and all flop. I did like the taste but it was just an average pie. I won't go back.