Salerno's Cafe

Thicker for the area, very good crust.

Heard this place may be selling to a new owner soon, not sure if the pizza will still be around or change so had to make a visit just in case. Barely makes it to the 8s for me but the crust is solid. Don’t like the sauce, it’s thicker and has a weird taste to it (too many seasonings maybe), was looking forward to a soupy like cheese like in the prez review but the cheese looks blah and doesn’t have any unique characteristics, it’s ok if you’re looking for American (I get why it was rated the lowest old forge style). I got x cheese, x sauce, and plain, because I didn’t like the sauce the extra cheese was best bc it overpowers while still getting to enjoy the crust. Good restaurant overall and worth going for dinner and drinks, just wont miss the za.

Very light crust. Good flavor.

Open faced white and red pizzas. Both were delicious! Crust is light, airy and crunchy. Sauce on the red definitely hits the spot.

Fluffy stuff.

Different than Philly area pizza but good

No flop, doesn’t look like anything special but looks are deceiving. Very good pizza.

My first Old Forge experience. It reminds me of school lunch pizza. Undercooked and underflavored.

People were great. Pizza was super light. Cheese was a weird liquid kinda blend. Stuck to mouth every bite. Just not my style.

Old Forge square style tray. Crispy crust soft gooey center.

Solid sauce. Light and fluffy crust. Good amount of cheese. Would of liked a crisper crust. Would order again

Little crisp on the bottom.... Not really strong sauce flavor.... Good cheese to sauce ratio...

Best of Old Forge. Served hot. Crispy.

Dough not as good as the other two places but the cheese had more taste. Pretty good.

Awesome pizza! Cheesy, crispy crust!

Extreme cheese and a nice crunchy but light crust just lacking the sauce but over all great tasting!