Sally's Apizza

Amazing

Incredible pizza. The king of New Haven

The sauce, cheese, and undercarriage were amazing. A little too burnt on the crust for my liking. Still an amazing pizza with good service!

Absolutely lives up to the hype

Solid pizza. Maybe not worth the hour wait though.

Best pizza ever!! Sauce is amazing and cooked perfectly.

Incredible. Let it cool just a minute and it’s a top tier pizza. Both pep and mato pies are killer. Crust is perfect, sauce is tangy, and cheese is kinda spot on tasty bitter. Ronis have excellent flavor as well. Hype is definately real. Delish

Decent crust and undercarriage A little flop, not much Great tomato sauce flavor A little too much sauce to cheese ratio

Really good pizza - glad I waited in line. Pepperoni half better than sausage half. Came out steaming hot but got cold quick.

Was hoping for more tbh

My first 9+. I could crush a whole large by myself. Does not disappoint.

Floppy, chewy and a sweet sauce. Drove a long way to get here and try it. What a letdown!

Probably the best pizza I’ve ever had. Fantastic.

The clam was so light and tasty. Perfect amount of char.

Look I get it is not a great photo but this is hands down the best pizza in the world not a lot of cheese which I like it is sooo good worth the wait.

Sally’s was above average. It lives on its reputation from its prior ownership.