Sally's Apizza

The pizza to my family was only ok. We expected a wait, which ended up being an hour and a half for pickup. In this time we went to another major pizza spot in New Haven, waited 20 minutes for takeout and got better pizza. The cheese and sauce to me were uninspired. We got a cheese and a pizza with lots of toppings, and the mushrooms were undercooked, but the cheese pizza was lacking passion.

The pizza sauce was great. Crust was good and crispy but the middle was floppy . Overall great pizza.

High hopes were met. Outrageous all around. A tad too floppy to get into the 9s but that was the only score killer

now this is saucyboss420 approved. sauce tastes fresh and very flavorful. little bit of flop tho needed a second longer. worth the wait, my pizza place should take notes

Great, great pizza. Worth the long wait. Sauce and crust incredible, undercarriage to die for. A little New Haven flop, but overall a dominant pie.

Pretty good pizza. We drove from brooklyn to give it a try. Definitely not my favorite

Very good pizza. However small style pepperonis are usually not my favorite and although the sauce was incredible I thought cheese needed more flavor. Expect burnt edges on the crust but soft throughout.

Pretty flawless. Everything you want in a pizza

It’s pizza…

There’s a reason I’ve only done three reviews on this app, I don’t waste my time with 6.2’s. Just an unreal pie. Second 10 ever. I can’t put into words. Life changing pizza.

Just like the video! Had to try it! Fresh ingredients! Delicious! Loved the pepperoni!

Best pizza I’ve ever had. Light, thin, crispy and unreal fresh flavor. New Haven style is Everything you want in a pizza. 2 hour wait in line was worth it. Restaurant is super old and cool.

very good but very greasy. huge line. not a 9.2 tho

The best sauce you’ll have, just need a bit more cheese and a 9+

Pretty good but it ain’t new york

Sauce taste great. Would have preferred a little more cheese. Decent char but was expecting more of a crunch. The cheese was better than the pepperoni. Need to give it a 2nd try.

Sauce was impeccable, good crust. Cannot go wrong with this pizza

So close. So so so fucking close to perfect.