A great pizza if it was just a little thicker with the same crunch that’s about as close to a 10/10 as you can get
seth.dietz6/18/21, 11:38 p.m.
Phenomenal pizza. Perfectly crispy charred crust, flavorful sauce, and quality cheese and other toppings. Tough to beat.
carmine.simonelli6/18/21, 7:10 p.m.
The No Crust Pizza. Had to order Extra Cheese. If not, would of been a 6.5 at best. Crunchy good undercarriage. A tad over cooked, I like a well done pie.. this was to much.
pizzakingcroton6/14/21, 11:02 a.m.
This pizza is very good, but it’s definitely not world class. Seems like the myth of this place plays more in the rating than the actual quality. If you’re in New Haven, try it. But don’t make a trip to come here.
john.chase16/14/21, 4:42 a.m.
The best of The New Haven style and the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. Appreciate it, enjoy it, eat it.
dylan.grenier6/13/21, 9:59 p.m.
Very beautiful looking pie. First time I ever tried it as a CT resident, very very good. Something about the cheese and/or sauce combination tastes so great. Pepperoni was very good and thicker than most places cut them. No shaker cheese or pepper flakes needed, but do taste good on it as well. Need to try!!
bryan.irish6/13/21, 7:22 p.m.
The very definition of New Haven style pizza. Thin, cooked well-done and delicious. If you like this style of pizza, Sally’s is as near perfection as you’re going to get!
subdiver6/9/21, 11:59 p.m.
Very good pizza but not as good as the hype. Sauce on their regular pie (8.3) is very good but not enough cheese on mine, why? The crust is nice and charred from one of those old ovens. Their clam pie (7.9) is not as good as Frank Pepe’s. They need to put more chunkier clams and not look like mall pizza. It’s good but not great. Overall, 8.1, still a good score.
louis.iovino16/6/21, 8:58 p.m.
Finally got my lips on this pie. We ordered half tomato with garlic and half mozzarella. Pizza had great flop, thin with some oil gracing the underbody. Crust was the icing on the cake!!! Delicious to the last bite. Worth the trip
ringosghost6/5/21, 6:05 a.m.
So second leg on family pizza road trip. First had Frank Pepes. (See that review too) Again excellent pizza. So good. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Excellent quality ingredients. I scored Frank Pepes 9.1 and this pizza here a 9.2. I preferred the sauce to cheese ratio slightly better here to out this one a check bite. Rest of family liked Frank Pepes better. But they are both excellent. Road trip worthy.
sean.bradfield6/2/21, 8:27 p.m.
Best pizza in New Haven. Very light pizza, crisp but still has a good chew
pizzaqueen075/30/21, 8:44 p.m.
Enjoyed this one. Sauce was super tasty.. sweet and tangy. We added basil on top which made a huge difference. Like this a whole lot more than frank Pepe’s. Crust was yummy. Definitely worth it.
aaron.gibbs5/30/21, 6:45 p.m.
Solid, solid pie. Excellent crisp, great balance of sauce and cheese and did I mention the Crisp 👍
16 views•0 likes