Sal's Pizza Cedarburg

FINALLY made it to Sals Pizza - Cedarburg and it didn’t disappoint!! Officially my new favorite spot in Wisconsin, passing Wells Bros and Zaffiro's on Farwell. This is authentic NY style, owners are from Brooklyn. Fresh dough made in house daily, grande cheese, delicious sauce and hearty, flavor sausage. End crust was crispy on the outside, soft and airy on the inside. Undercarriage crunchy front to back and still crunchy 20+ mins out of the overn. Just like the owner says on social media "where are you gonna get this? Nowhere! Fuggedaboudit!!"

Hard to find a good sicilian style in Milwaukee. Really tasty pesto/mozzarella/parmesan combo topping.

Bit of flop even when well done and average flavor. Solid pie, but nothing that sets it apart from other local joints.

Good crust and amount of toppings. Had some flop, and sauce doesn’t have a ton of flavor.

We love the garlic notes and workers!

$5+ for a slice and 2.50 for can of soda. As far the pizza goes. Very good NY style. Little flop but excellent crisp from first to last bite. A very solid option for lunch locally and pretty appropriately scored.

Great NY style slice. Garlic knot was a nice bonus

Quality New York style pizza! Little greasy otherwise over 8 score. Crispy crust! prefer little more well done pizza. No flop unless ordering toppings which we did on 2nd pizza.

Nice crisp and taste. No flop. Good cheese to sauce ratio

Excellent crunch and great specials! Very supportive of veterans 🇺🇸

Free garlic with a slice is huge...

One of the better pizza places in the area for sure

God basic pizza - always good service - totally worth stopping in

Ok pizza. Super flop

Sauce + flavor = 😁 Crust = 🤔 Price = 🙂

Very good pizza. Good crisp, sauce, cheese. A little greasy... that kept it out of the 8 range.

Solid slice

The best slice in Ozaukee County, hands down. The best crust in the area, tasty sauce, and just so darn good.