Stefanina's Pizzeria & Restaurant O'Fallon

Gave it another try, surprisingly worse than before. The dough / crust is the most pathetic thing I’ve seen on pizza. Worse than any frozen pizza I’ve had and have no idea how someone could give this more than 2 chances… it’s really that bad.

Real close to being in the 7’s but it was undercooked for my taste. Generally liked the taste overall but the crust just let me down. A little more sauce and a few more minutes in the oven it’s likely 7.4 at least. Maybe a second try will change my mind. For now, it’s rated a 6.9.

Pretty average pizza. Taste like crust is premade

As locally- commercial as I will go with pizza. It was super hot, filled with toppings, and crisp. The crust was oddly flavorless- truly with the consistency and dryness of a cracker. Our selection came with amazing service and a true love for her customers. That IS a review!

Best STL pizza! Perfect cheese blend, super crispy crust! Kicks IMOs ass!

Probably the second best thin crust pizza in STL behind Imo’s

We got two pizzas from here. One cheese and one with pepperoni and bacon. If I was just reviewing the cheese pizza I would probably give it a 6.1; however with the meat a 6.5 feels pretty solid. It only had a little bit of flop with an interesting tang to it.

Not much flop but it’s St. Louis style. Excellent cheese to sauce ratio.