The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar

The pizza scores are consistent with both One Bite and Dave’s reviews. I’m a bit biased toward pizzas that are crispy with a lighter sauce profile. My ideal slice is light, crisp, and slightly salty, with a sauce that isn’t overly sweet—and that’s exactly what this pizza delivers.

Great crisp, amazing flavor in the crust. Came early for lunch and they did not disappoint!

This is the best NY slice I’ve ever had and definitely one of the best pizzas. Johnnys Special. Unreal

Best Pizza I’ve had outside of New Haven/New York area. Great atmosphere as well.

I stopped by here on my way back home from Monroe, Michigan. This is the greatest pizza I’ve ever had!! The spicy Sicilian is probably my favorite but any of their NY style are perfect also

Good stuff

Would be better with extra sauce. Good crispy crust.

Solid pizza spot!

Huge slice, tastes great and the crust has that nice crisp. Great lunch special too.

Absolutely fantastic!!! No flop, great sauce and dough, no grease. And they have slices!

Second best pizza in Toledo behind village idiot

Was great tasting but it was greasy. Had a hard time keeping it together. May have just been a dud pie. Worth a visit

I've been here a few times now and this place never disappoints! I make the drive from an hour away for this pie because it's absolutely delicious! I got the meat lovers and it was excellent.

Under carriage was floppy, sauce and dough was delicious, overall tasty

It’s great it’s like eating captain crunch very crisp

Good but little too overdone almost felt like I was chewing sand

Great New York slice, no flop, crispy undercarriage. Best I’ve had in Toledo or BG.