Wiseguy Pizza Pie

Excellent undercarriage with just the right amount of flop. Sauce was dialed in—not overly sweet. The staff made you feel like you were the only customer in the place.

I enjoyed it being molten hot out of the oven. Good crisp on the crust. All around good pizza.

Really good. Crispy, great crust, lite. You could house a medium easy by yourself.

Looks like a 6, but tastes like a 7, which is why it squeaked up to a 7.1. A thin slice with no flop and a little char is the way to my heart and the way this slice came together led me to housing the whole thing. With higher quality ingredients and a Woodfire grill, this could be a banger. Definitely worth a shot if you’re in the area! 7.1, that’s the review!

This is far better than expected given the remote location. Decent sauce, a little more would have helped, nice bake. On par with pizza back home on the East Coast. I can’t imagine there’s anything better within a several hundred miles

Solid ski town pie….not quite New York style, but very little flop, great crunch. Crust could use a bit more salt, but I’ve got to be honest Frankie….it’s not bad. How’s my hair…..that’s a review.

A solid slice of pizza. Pretty crispy with nice flavor.

Best pizza in the valley!

Amazing. Best in Idaho.

Actually pretty good. Lots of Idaho flop. Crust is nothing special but you can tell it’s very fresh. No complaints at all

Good dough. Nice crunch. No flop. Not a lot of flavor in the sauce or toppings.

Not terrible but definitely not anywhere in the 7s. Probably the best in the town though Forsure.

The wifey gives this pizza a 8.3! Front desk gal 1.1 🤷🏻‍♂️

¡El Presidente! This is great spot to grab a solid slice if you are ever skiing/boarding in Sun Valley.