John's of Bleecker Street

Best pizza I’ve had in NYC!

Stopped in a few weeks ago because of all the hype. I had high hopes but I was disappointed after an hour in line. In my opinion it doesn’t hold a candle to anything in New Haven (Sally’s, Pepe’s, Modern or Bar). The dough was undercooked, wasn’t a fan of the clumps of sauce and toppings were sub par.

Gold standard

The ingredients taste so fresh, this pie is so good! My first Authentic New York pizza didn’t disappoint!

My taste buds want to say 10 but my pride says 9.7 It’s like someone took all the love in the world and put it into pizza.. you take a bite and you feel like you fell in love. Everybody knows the rules.

YUMM

Ordered to-go to avoid the line. Had it ready in 15 mins. Ate it immediately outside. Fantastic. Came to NYC specifically to consume the best pizza possible. Left feeling accomplished.

Worth enduring the line and a bickering girlfriend for this.

I was crying

This is a must try pizza if you live in North America. The sauce, crust, cheese is to die for, and the pie was cooked to perfection. IMO, it’s the best in NYC

Coal fired pizza can’t get much better than this.

Best pizza in New York. A must try

Mmmmmmmm mmmmm MMMM

What the boss said. Fantastic

Amazing! Delicious! So good! Wish we had gotten a plain cheese as well to round out the experience.

An excellent pizza. Hard to imagine a pizza much better. Great sauce, cheese, and crust. A cool interior as well in this old-timey pizzeria.

very yummy

Cheese was the best part. Nice char on the crust as well.