Gino's Of Williston Park

OK, here we are on a gorgeous but a bit chilly Monday. Great win Friday night against John Jay. Finished the season 6-2. What a season it was. Senior season. Can’t believe it’s almost over. Now onto playoffs. Good weekend in fire Island as well. I wanted to get a good pizza review in. So here we go. Dave reviewed this, and gave it a pretty good review. Now it’s a tad greasy. But still very good. Little bit of Long Island flop, a tad doughy. But to be expected. But still very good. Crisp this sucker up, and it would definitely be high seven’s low eights. Good peeps working in the pizzeria. A good Monday review.

Not my particular cup of tea! I’m not an onion fan and they are heavy handed with the onions in their sauce! The crust is also unnecessarily thick. The crust for margherita slice had pretty good flavor which saved the overall review but the grandma was pretty chewy and the Buffalo chicken slice…I normally like when it’s saucy but they went overkill and it tasted like they just used a bottle Franks Hot Sauce! ⭐️Margherita - 5.5 ⭐️Grandma - 5.0 ⭐️Buffalo - 4.0

Reg: Undercarriage is cooked really nice. Very crispy. Sauce tastes good. Cheese is good. The sauce to cheese ratio is in favor of the cheese. If they are not equal, I would prefer more sauce 7.6 Grandma: Undercarriage is excellent. Sauce has a really good flavor, and the cheese compliments everything perfectly. This a real good Grandma 8.5

Great sauce and cheese

The halo crust was the best of the 3. Regular needed more sauce and Sicilian was overly spiced. Decent but Da-Angelo down block is the better option

Wasn't a fresh slice so that's probably why it's a low score.

Tastey hard crust good cheese lacking in sauce tho

Woke up last morning, got yourself a gun, your mama told you….. that’s how I felt walking into this pizza Joint. Four old school Italianos shooting the breeze straight out of an episode of Sopranos. The accents, the jewelry, the back room they all went to afterwards. Anyways, on to the pizza. Not bad at all!! Flavorful, touch of oregano that hits the spot and crispy crust. I still think Dangelos down the block is slightly better, but this spot holds its own. Enjoy!!

Buffalo chicken slice. Very good. Spicy and crunchy chicken. Crust is very good.

Penne a la vodka slice

Really solid slice. Cooked extremely well with minimal flop. Pretty tasty too. Biggest flaw is it’s a bit too greasy.

Good crust. Not a bad flop. No one flavor overwhelming. Decent cheese. The outer crust could be thicker and better. The sauce could use a bit more flavor. Overall, good slice.

OK so with this pizza it’s literally covered in fucking grease the amount of grease that falls off this pizza you can fill a shot glass with it’s very cheesy it’s got a very good crisp The crust is very good and the sauce is really good as well it’s just there’s very little of it

Top 3 Sicilian slice! Almost as good as L and Bs. Amazing tho and Pres should def come out and try this! Tastes amazing and great crunchy outside that balances the gooey dough.

2nd time around, Frank was here. Crunchy slice with no flop. Lots of cheese with less sauce, cracker like crust. Fantastic slice.

Best Sicilian ever!

Chicken Parm slice. But heard Sicilian is a 9. This was really good.. really crispy... would def get again.

Best pizza in town. My spot to go to

Great crust, amazing sauce!