Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street

First off the large is a LARGE!!!! Pretty greasy but solid under carriage. I could see this being a great drunk pie

Definitely got good drunk pizza vibes

Crispy crust is buttery very high quality pizza . Dough made in house. You won’t be disappointed!

Really good pizza. A little bit of flop on the crust in the slice I had but definitely would go back and have again

Love Goodfellas Pizza anywhere I find them. This was too crisp for me why the low score but this is typically always between the 8-9 range

This place just hits perfect

Solid pizza, good undercarriage, nice crunch to the outer crust. A bit greasy. Would definitely order again.

Huge dinner plate sized nipple pepperonis were the best part. Hit the spot for late night, but to put this in the category of a must visit would be silly. Slices are massive so there is definitely some serious floppage and the pizza box has to be tilted just to get through the door. Excellent customer service inside even for how busy they were when we went late night. Most people are grumpy that late but these folks welcomed everyone.

Drunk pizza

Slice was huge, maybe a little too big even, pepperoni was the size of my head. Didn’t get a chance to dive into this one right away so may have brought it down a bit for me, a little crisp/crunch in that crust would do wonders. Place has to be drunk slice heaven with all the bars around downtown. 10 for the staff in there - nice group of guys working in there

Goodfellas is great, fellas

Amazing chew to the crust with fresh and tasty sauce and high quality mozzarella!

I’m from jersey so i know my way around a pizza. little light on the sauce. good size for the price. nice garlic flavor and great crust. little flop action, but good flop. Closest you can get to new york/jersey style pizza in kentucky

Good crust and flavor.

Underwhelming it’s just not that good very bland

Decent pie not a lot of flop but not a lot of taste either. Could use more sauce

Best in Lexington and possibly the state. Perfectly cooked. Tangy sauce.

Great pizza when it’s fresh! Not so much if it’s not!! About 50 percent of the time it’s fresh.

Not bad pizza. Having trouble typing this cause all the fucking grease tho. I would come back..